American Idol 7 Results: 4/23/08 (Part Un)

Okay, so I just got home. My bro, J-Fred, was in town and I opted for dinner and beers with him instead of staying in to watch AI and making the ass-groove in my couch even deeper.

Apparently, Carly was voted off last night. Apparently, she was kind of a whiny, sore loser. I will have to watch the action on YouTube some time today and compile my thoughts. But, in the meantime, let me say that I'm happy that my little dreadlocked Travolta-boy is still around to amuse me with his stoner expressions and sparkly eyes.

Comments

Gifted Typist said…
Carly was quite poised and dignified about it, I thought.

The fact that neither Jason and Brooke didn't get in the B2 suggests that the idiot pit expands far beyond the front of the stage.
Dale said…
Another shocker vote off. Now she and Michael Johns can be together! Hi Beckeye! :-)
SkylersDad said…
I agree with GT, Carly was totally cool with the results. It was a big surprise to see Brooke safe and Carly voted off to me.
Editor said…
Brooke was safe BECAUSE she dared to make a mistake, making her seem human.

Arch was safe because every freaking tennybopper in the world watches this show (38 million votes and only about 10 of them are old enough to vote).

Cook was safe because he actually has some (some being the operative word) talent.

Jason was safe because he acted like he hated singing Memories (he should have rolled his eyes while singing it to be more effective).

I have no idea why Syesha was safe...
Fran said…
My stepdaughter was watching this last night.

It scared me so I just left the room and drank a lot.

Oh wait - I would have probably done that anyway.
Anonymous said…
I am a happily married woman, but something about Jason Castro does make me feel like a giggly little school girl. I just really hope that he kicks it up a notch next week, or else he doesn't deserve to be there.

I thought that maybe it was just the teen girl / older women with innappropriate crushes vote keeping him in, but even my husband loves his voice. I guess it's the Cat Stevens vibe that we like.
cube said…
Castro's voice is weak. Weak, I tell you! It's not a charisma competition, it's about singing.

I'm getting soooo sick of AI.
Falwless said…
YOU FAT RACIST WHORE.
Falwless said…
Oh shit, forgot I was logged in. That was supposed to be from "anonymous."

hehe..

The fact that Carly left before Brooke and Syesha is retarded. That is all.
Red said…
Yeah. Carly actually seemed a bit relieved or something. Still, I call bullshit.
I did not get a shiner vibe at all...Jason is so weak...sorry he is...and he should have gone home...

He was whispering all sorts of snide remarks to Carly from the moment he and Carly left backstage until they announced he was safe and she was getting a stool...

He seemed to be acting like a little toad....
GingerSnaps said…
Yep, I once again call bullshit that the most talented artists are now gone.

Brooke must have gotten the sympathy vote. She was just as shocked to still be standing as we were!
Claire said…
I was really sorry to see her go, I thought she was great on Tuesday. She was actually gracious, not sure who thought she was whiny.
Chancelucky said…
Carly was very gracious. I haven't been a fan, but I was sorry to see her go.
The highlight of Wednesday was Jason Castro yawning at the camera and Ryan finally kissing Simon.
Anonymous said…
I too think Carly was cool about getting voted off.

Funny... I didn't care for her performance (or anyone's except the Davids' for that matter) on Tuesday night, but I thought she was great last night. I wouldn't mind seeing her fronting a rock band.

I can't believe I'm going to say this, but I think Pauler is right about one thing: by now, each of the remaining contestants has a "ginormous" fan base, people who will vote for them no matter what. Especially with all the controversy surrounding her, I don't think Carly's fan base is as "ginormous" as either David's or Jason's, as evidenced by her numerous appearances in the bottom. Same for the two remaining females, only minus the controversy.
Cup said…
You're suggesting some other chick with your beloved? You have a big heart, B'Eye.
Claire said…
I did the meme you tagged me for.
I'll bet your ass groove missed you.
BeckEye said…
BETH - I assume you're referring to Dale's ridiculous comment. I would NEVER allow my beloved to be with someone else. Well, except his wife because I can't do anything about that. At least not until my mind completely snaps.
Leonesse said…
Wait, he's married? Wow.

It's only because he hasn't met you yet. You know that already.